Study finds that a program was implemented to eliminate police officers from certain % calls in Denver. This helped decrease crime

Wednesday, June 8, 2022
author picture Ethan Guerin
Video/image : YouTube
Original content created by staff

Mental Health 911 Calls

In the wake of two high-profile suicides and the murder of a New York woman, police have taken a hard look at the way they respond to 911 calls related to mental health crises. Police officers are often the first responders, and while the vast majority of people with mental illnesses do not engage in violent behavior, calls to 911 about them do. To counter this problem, advocates are calling for specific guidelines on when to call police, and for a separate emergency line for mental health calls.

A program in Denver According to Wednesday's study, removing certain police officers from % calls resulted in a 34% decrease in low-level crime. This was despite a rising wave of cities shifting their mental health crisis responses. The Program Support Team Assistance Response (or STAR): The results of the six-month pilot, which began in June 2020 and ended in June 2020, showed that nearly 1400 crimes were prevented. According to Thomas Dee (a Stanford graduate school of education professor who studies public policy), we think that we have something really significant in terms of suggesting radical changes in how emergency responders are handled. Since 2020's deaths, calls to reform policing have intensified and the growth of other nonpolice intervention programs has increased. George Floyd in Minneapolis and  Daniel Prude Rochester, New York: A man who had been suffering from a mental illness when he was taken into police custody and died. Experts in law enforcement and mental health agree that % calls about substance abuse disorders, mental illness, and homelessness do not require a response from the police. According to ACDC, more than one in five people who have been shot dead by police were suffering from a mental disorder. Washington Post database On-duty officers may be responsible for fatal shootings. MORE ON THE STAR PROGRAM: Denver sent not police but mental health professionals to many calls. Similar programs were also created in New York, Washington  and San Francisco The organizers point to the Eugene program, Crisis Assistance Helping out On The Streets (or CAHOOTS), as an example of success. Although the program's specific structure may vary from one city to the next, the aim is to bring together mental health professionals and emergency medical technicians in order to assist with certain % calls rather than police officers. These programs differ from Crisis Intervention Training For Police and Co-responder Models, which pairs police officers with other responders. Dee stated that there is much to love about this program regardless of whether you support back-to-blue politics or want to defund police officers. Denvers Support Team Assisted Response program (STAR) paired clinicians with medics to address disorderly conduct and drug abuse.

The Denver pilot's success

The pilot was conducted in Denver by two teams consisting of a physician and a nurse. It took place in a van between 10 a.m. and 6 p.m. every weekday in eight precincts. While the Stanford Study was focused on data about crime related to offenses that were mainly targeted by the program, including trespassing, disorderly conduct and drug abuse, it also looked at trends in criminal acts such as theft or weapons charges. The pilot's data was analyzed, as well as the data in eight precincts that the pilot worked and the ones it did not. Dee stated that police were not removed from % calls to target specific types of crimes. This contradicts the belief that low-level crime prevents serious crime. Dee stated that the analysis took into account a number of variables which could have contributed to the crime reduction in the area. These factors included the year, crime trends, and crime rates in precincts in which the pilot was conducted. Its Working in OLYMPIA AND EUGENE, TOO Police are not the only ones who send out civilians to respond to mental health emergencies. More cities have this capability. The STAR teams were created to help people in need of care and not to arrest or issue a citation. Dee pointed out genuine and authentic decreases in crime. He said that it wasn't just the fact that no police officers responded; there were also fewer recorded crimes. Over the period of six months, there was fewer incidents than would otherwise have received a response from police. The researchers found that STARs responses to 748 calls could have resulted in an anticipated 1,047 fewer crimes. Over the course of the six-month period, there were 1,376 less offenses in the eight precincts. Dee stated that the data revealed that the number of recorded offenses was lower in hours when STAR was not operating in precincts where pilots are held. Mental health problems can lead to relapse. When there is a behavioral problem, there can be a form of recidivism for these low-level criminal acts. Dee stated that by offering health care instead of arrest (STAR), it may have prevented recidivism and prevented future events for someone who is not receiving treatment. According to the study, the six-month pilot cost $208,141. This means that the 1,376 less offenses would have to be reduced at a rate of $151. Based on the costs of imprisonment and prosecution, each offense would have cost $646. % CALLS AND THE MENTAL HEALTH CRISIS For mental health emergencies, % dispatchers need to be trained better. This is why it's important. Ve Gulbrandsen (center), an EMT for CAHOOTS screens guests at the Egan Warming Center, Springfield, Ore. in March 2021.

Denver program grows

As the STAR program continues to grow, the Study was published in Science Advances. Vinnie Cervantes is a member of the Denver Alliance for Street Health Response. She also serves as a member on the STAR Community Advisory Committee. Cervantes said that the original idea for the program was born several years ago, just before it launched during the COVID-19 pandemic. Cervantes stated that Cervantes and Cervantes felt that there was a better way to help our unhoused community. Cervantes explained that the community that is experiencing substance abuse (disorders) as well as those in mental crisis, was compelled by the fact that these issues are growing, particularly with the pandemic. The six-month pilot in Denver's center has grown and STAR teams are responding to more calls than ever before, according to Tristan Sanders (director of community and behavioral healthcare for Denver's Department of Public Health and Environment). For the entire year, it has an estimated budget of between $1.3 million and $1.6 million.

Sanders stated that half of the funds come from a city tax initiative, which created the Caring for Denver Foundation. The other half comes from general city taxes dollars. IS THE COUNTRY EXPECTED FOR 988 Soon, the suicide helpline number will be in the 3s. Sanders stated that the Stanford study's results show the value of the expansion. This is a testimony to the quality of the triage process and how it was done. He said that the STAR response was the correct response when they are received in the proper manner. Cervantes stated that the STAR program's early results are clearly better than police having to show up in all kinds of situations they don't need. He hopes the program will be able to serve more communities that are most affected by violence from police and mental disorders as it expands. A community response program's core idea is to connect people with longer-term care services and options after the crisis has been de-escalated. That is what we don't have. Cervantes stated that we are trying to build it right now. Sanders stated that plans were in place to add more community-based services into the response. After a STAR Call, housing and food were identified by Sanders as primary additional needs. He stated that the goal was to warmly hand off information to other community agencies, and not only a brochure. Sanders stated that he anticipates an increase in call volume and response volume as the program grows and meets more demand. It should be able to reach a point where emergency response will not be as necessary because the people's immediate needs can be met. Sanders stated that this might be the most accessible line of support for some people right now. It would be great if there was a meaningful network of support that existed in five to seven years. However, people access it differently and its really accessible for everyone. It is meeting many people in an extremely meaningful manner. You can reach the U.S. if you think that someone is suffering from suicidal thoughts. National Suicide Prevention Lifeline Call 800-273-TALK (8255), any time of the day, night or weekend chat online. Crisis Text Line People in distress can also get confidential 24/7 support by text messaging if they call 741741. Original publication: USA TODAY Study shows that Denver's non-police departments have reduced the crime rate by responding to some % calls.